Shredding Grinding or Granulating – Which is right for me
Time:2019-01-09
Shredder, grinder, and granulator are often used interchangeably, but they perform very different size reduction tasks. Choosing the wrong machine wastes capital, reduces output quality, and can damage equipment. The right choice depends on two factors: your input material and your required output size. Here’s how to match the machine to your application.
Start by identifying your material — plastic, paper, rubber, PVC, municipal solid waste, construction debris, medical waste, or other. Then define your target output size. Need pieces around 50 mm or larger? You likely need a shredder. Need chips under 12 mm? Consider a grinder or granulator. Many operations use two stages: a shredder for primary reduction, then a grinder or granulator for secondary sizing.
Shredding: Primary Size Reduction
Shredders operate at low speed and high torque. They take large, bulky items and break them into random, irregular pieces typically 25–50 mm or larger. Shredding is the right choice when you need to:
Reduce volume for transport or landfill compaction
Break tires into chips for fuel or civil engineering fill
Destroy paper, documents, or products for liability or security reasons
Prepare plastics for washing or further processing
Handle mixed, contaminated, or tough materials that would jam faster machines
Grinding: Secondary Reduction to Chips
Grinding produces smaller, more consistent output than shredding — typically 6–12 mm chips. A grinder uses high-speed rotors with closed designs and tight tolerances to shear material into uniform particles. Grinding fits applications such as:
Regrinding large rejected parts for recycling back into production
Reducing raw materials to chip size for compounding or blending
Processing organic waste for biofuel production
Recovering fibers from carpet and textiles
Grinding turns raw or rejected rubber and plastic into feedstock for new products — bottles, tires, storage containers, and more.
Granulating: Fine Output for Reuse
Granulators and grinders both reduce material size, but granulators achieve finer output — down to 5 mm flakes or even powders. The key difference is rotor design:
Open rotor (granulators): Plenty of air space around the rotor for cooling and agitation. Ideal for light, hollow, or thin-walled materials like plastic bottles, film, and small injection molded parts.
Closed rotor (grinders): High-speed, tight-tolerance design that forces material directly across cutting edges. Better for dense, solid, or thick-walled items.
Granulators typically handle feed sizes from 12 mm to 200 mm and are often used after a shredder or grinder for final sizing. They excel at producing clean, uniform particles ready for extrusion, injection molding, or compounding.
Quick Selection Guide
Answer these four questions to narrow your choice:
1.What material are you reducing? — Rigid, soft, hollow, or mixed?
2.What is the input size? — Whole pallets, pipes, sheets, or small rejects?
3.What output size do you need? — 50 mm chunks, 10 mm chips, or sub-5 mm granules?
4.What is your required throughput? — Kilograms or tons per hour?
Rule of thumb: Start with a shredder for bulky, tough, or contaminated material. Add a grinder or granulator when you need fine, uniform output. For light plastics and bottles, go straight to a granulator. Wanrooe application engineers can help you finalize the configuration based on your specific material test results.
FAQ: Shredder vs Grinder vs Granulator
Can I use a granulator for large plastic pallets?
No. Granulators are designed for smaller feed sizes. Large pallets will jam the rotor and damage blades. Use a shredder first, then a granulator for final sizing.
Do I need both a shredder and a grinder?
Often yes, if your input is large and your output must be small. A shredder handles primary reduction efficiently; a grinder or granulator then produces the precise particle size your process requires. Running large material directly through a grinder wastes energy and wears blades prematurely.
Which machine is best for plastic film?
A granulator with an open rotor. Film is light and tends to wrap around closed rotors. The open design allows air circulation that keeps film from agglomerating and overheating.
Leave a Reply